Grokipedia and Google's Impossible Choice
The chances are, if you're reading this you have at the very least a better than average understanding of how Google works; you understand what crawling is, what indexing is, how Google uses links - both internal and external - to understand the structure and popularity of a website, and probably even how the choice of technology you use to build and render your website can affect Google's perception of it.
As such, you might have seen Grokipedia, Elon Musk's AI powered version of Wikipedia that got released in the last few days, and immediately thought "well, it'll be interesting to see how well that ranks". The content on the site is proudly AI generated (slash slightly less proudly copied directly from Wikipedia in a lot of places), there's basically no internal linking, the homepage is just a searchbar, the content is weird and jilted; all the things that we as SEOs would highlight as real problems if we took the site on as a client.
And, because of this I've seen plenty of people say "Well, I guess we'll see what happens if your site is run by Elon Musk", suggesting some sort of impropriety on Google's part, but to me Grokipedia has become the perfect encapsulation of a fight Google can simply never, ever win.
Let's, for a second, forget being an SEO. Let's say you're a big Elon Musk fan who doesn't know anything about Google, but you know Elon has released his own "Non-Woke" version of Wikipedia, and you notice that it never really seems to show up when you search for things. This, you deduce, is due to silicon valley being run by blue haired non-binary people, and is a perfect demonstration of the bias of the liberal elites in the tech industry.
However, if you're an SEO, or you don't think Musk is great, you have plenty of reason to believe that Grokipedia shouldn't rank, so when it does it's very easy to wonder how much of this is to do with Sundar Pichai having dinner with Trump, or how much Google are scared of the legal might of the richest man in the world and are preemptively acquiescing to keep themselves safe.
And this is Google's problem. They've decided they aren't going to tell us how or why they make these decisions, and that's come back to bite them in the arse.
The site, the algorithm and their attitude to how ranking works were all invented during that brief blip in time where we seemingly believed that history was over; democracy had won, the Berlin wall had fallen, and it would have seemed totally crazy to suggest that a private company choosing not to link to a website could ever be considered a political decision. And yet.
And yet.
Google famously do not reveal the details of their ranking algorithm, which is fine but also it means that it becomes very difficult for them to demonstrate why sites do or don't rank how they do (Although the aftermath of the HCU suggests that actually, Google don't know how the algorithm works anymore anyway, and all they can do is make updates and see what happens) because a) Any piece of solid information from Google will be seized upon by SEOs like ants on a discarded double lolly, and b) Google is now so monolithic and so ubiquitous, everything they do or don't do in this regard is a political decision. Choosing to rank Grokipedia because of who it belongs to and what it is is a political decision. Choosing not to is a political decision.
And of course, from a commercial perspective, it behooves Google to rank websites that "should" appear in the results. Remember the old days of big brands getting nuclear penalties? Those brands still ranked for brand terms, and it never felt like Google particularly wanted to stop Interflora appearing for "deliver flowers" because, ultimately, if I google that and interflora don't show up, as a clueless end user I kind of assume Google doesn't know what it's doing.
And here's the other thing: Google (and god forbid I be the one to defend Google) does its best to link to notable content that people are discussing, and literally the only reason anyone is discussing the site is because of Elon Musk, so the site is generating backlinks and citations as people like me write blogposts about it, which make it rank better, so yes, in a way the site being owned by Musk IS going to help it rank - but again, they can't just SAY this because it will emphasise just how much links still matter no matter how much they try to tell us they don't.
So here we are. We have a private company who are so big they basically are the internet to a lot of people, who have to decide whether or not to showcase (and thus sort of implicitly endorse) a website that doesn't meet a lot of their quality standards, but that a large number of users may well expect to see appear in the search results. Google are damned if they are, damned if they don't.